As Israel Retains Killing People, U.S. Officers Give It a Move


Share post:

Nearly 20 years earlier than Israeli forces killed Palestinian American journalist Shireen Abu Akleh, taking pictures a single bullet into her head whereas she was reporting from the occupied West Financial institution metropolis of Jenin, an Israeli soldier drove a bulldozer over American peace activist Rachel Corrie, crushing her to demise.

Each killings left little actual doubt in regards to the dynamics at play. Abu Akleh was standing with a gaggle of colleagues, sporting a vest clearly marked “PRESS,” nowhere close to the preventing that had taken place earlier that morning. Corrie was nonviolently protesting the demolition of a Palestinian household’s house in Gaza. She was sporting a fluorescent orange jacket with reflective stripes and had been on the scene for a number of hours, at occasions talking right into a megaphone.

Within the moments earlier than her demise, Corrie was standing within the path of the bulldozer as different activists had been doing all through the day. As the driving force pushed the machine ahead, she climbed onto a mound of dust so she can be clearly seen, in line with witness testimony reviewed by The Intercept. The motive force saved advancing. When she fell to the bottom, the dust engulfed her, however the driver moved a number of ft ahead earlier than backing off, successfully crushing her twice. The likelihood that he didn’t see her, as he later claimed, defies all credibility. Nonetheless, the Israeli authorities by no means took accountability for her demise, and whereas the U.S. authorities rejected the outcomes of the Israeli investigation, it did nothing to make sure that such a killing wouldn’t occur once more. So it did.

Rachel Corrie lies within the dust, ready for medical assist with three different Worldwide Solidarity Motion activists, after she was crushed underneath an Israeli bulldozer in Rafah, Gaza, on March 16, 2003.

Photograph: Worldwide Solidarity Motion/Getty Photographs

Corrie was killed on March 16, 2003, when she was 23. Twelve years later, on the anniversary of her demise, her dad and mom and sister met with Antony Blinken for the final time. The deputy secretary of state spoke to them within the honest manner they’d come to know nicely. “Come again anytime,” he advised them because the assembly got here to a detailed.

The Corries didn’t wish to come again. They’d been assembly with Blinken for years, and so they have been drained. When he requested, earnestly, “What can I do for you?” they felt annoyed. “I recognize your kindness,” Craig Corrie advised Blinken. “I’m glad you might be personally engaged. However except you have interaction your establishment, it doesn’t do me any good.”

“He’s asking, what can I do for you,” Cindy Corrie, Rachel’s mom, advised The Intercept. “However there’s some extent at which it’s like, what are you guys going to do?”

“I can’t let you know what instruments it’s important to use,” echoed Sarah, Rachel’s sister. “It’s essential be telling us.”

Rachel’s killing had introduced the Corries to tons of of places of work like Blinken’s through the years however nowhere nearer to the accountability they have been searching for. Blinken, at the moment the secretary of state, was considered one of a number of senior U.S. officers who labored carefully with the household throughout their yearslong campaign for justice and considered one of a quantity who now occupy prime positions within the Biden administration. The Corries favored him, and so they appreciated his efforts and heat. In emails, he signed himself “Tony.” He all the time responded to their letters and frequently met with them for longer than scheduled.

In the end, nevertheless, Blinken failed them.

As they ready to go away his workplace for the final time, Sarah advised him: “There was a promise made to the president of the US from Prime Minister [Ariel] Sharon of an intensive, credible, and clear investigation. Your authorities mentioned that that by no means occurred; that promise was by no means fulfilled,” she recalled. “You’ve nonetheless acquired an issue right here.”

Blinken nodded. “I do know.”

“I feel ultimately I wanted them to say no. In the event that they weren’t going to do something, that’s what I wanted to listen to out of that assembly.”

Strolling away, Sarah knew she was achieved. Blinken had requested her to comply with up with an electronic mail; she questioned why she must be the one do this, why one of many staffers within the room couldn’t take notes. “I felt like we might go on like this for the remainder of our lives,” she mentioned. “I feel ultimately I wanted them to say no. In the event that they weren’t going to do something, that’s what I wanted to listen to out of that assembly.”

Sarah was 29 when her sister was killed, and since then she had devoted herself fully to lobbying the U.S. authorities for motion. “You concentrate on what your life is in your 30s, creating your profession, elevating your loved ones,” she mentioned in an interview final month. “Mine was this course of.”

She had been identified with Crohn’s illness earlier than Rachel was killed, however the stress of the final 12 years had taken a toll on Sarah’s well being. The day of that assembly with Blinken, she felt too sick to get off the bed however powered by it. She had two extra conferences on the Senate that day. Within the hallway outdoors Blinken’s workplace, she remembered the phrases of one other senior official, Lawrence Wilkerson, Colin Powell’s chief of employees on the State Division on the time of Rachel’s demise: “You’re doing the best factor,” Wilkerson had warned the household. “However it’s possible you’ll by no means see outcomes, so don’t lose your well being.”

These phrases haunted Sarah now. “I’m not going to lose my well being over banging my head in opposition to the wall,” she lastly determined. “I knew at that time I couldn’t preserve doing this. I had reached my restrict.”

Cindy, Sarah and Craig Corrie at Sarah's home in Olympia, WA July 10, 2022. Kholood Eid for The Intercept

Cindy, Sarah, and Craig Corrie at Sarah’s house in Olympia, Wash., on July 10, 2022.

Photograph: Kholood Eid for The Intercept

That was in 2015. Since then, Cindy and Craig Corrie have continued to honor Rachel’s reminiscence by the Rachel Corrie Basis for Peace and Justice. They launched a sister metropolis partnership between Olympia, Washington, the place she grew up, and Rafah, town on the Egypt-Gaza border the place she was killed. They converse in assist of Palestinians at occasions world wide. In conferences with activists, Cindy generally discovered herself defending Blinken to critics of U.S. international coverage. “I advised them I did really feel this was particular person, who cared and did attempt to assist,” she mentioned. “And I imagine Tony Blinken desires the perfect for Palestinian individuals too.”

Blinken didn’t reply to The Intercept’s request for remark, however a State Division spokesperson wrote that the administration stood by the statements of earlier administrations. “Rachel Corrie’s demise was tragic and this administration reiterates our condolences to her household,” the spokesperson wrote. “The U.S. constantly known as for an intensive, credible, and clear investigation into Rachel Corrie’s killing.”

Sarah was not a lot of an activist herself, however she had seen it as her civic obligation to make sure that her authorities labored because it was imagined to. The endeavor of lobbying U.S. officers to do one thing about Rachel’s killing had turn into all-consuming, barely leaving time to grieve. After the final assembly with Blinken, she saved the piles of paperwork she had collected through the years and tried to deal with her life. She took up dance courses and flight classes.

When the Corries gave up, the U.S. authorities’s effort to get accountability for Rachel additionally got here to an finish. “After we stopped, they stopped,” mentioned Craig. “That wagon was in a bunch of mud. For those who weren’t pushing on it, you didn’t go wherever.”

Then in Might, Abu Akleh was killed. A number of unbiased investigations, together with one by the United Nations, concluded that she was shot by Israeli forces, describing the taking pictures as “focused” and the bullet that killed her as “well-aimed.” Her demise was referred to the Worldwide Legal Courtroom. However following a examined playbook in such conditions, the Israeli authorities refused to take accountability.

11 May 2022, Palestinian Territories, Gaza City: Children take part in a candlelight vigil to denounce the killing of Al Jazeera reporter Shireen Abu Akleh. Abu Akleh, 51, a prominent figure in the Arabic news service of the Al-Jazeera channel, was shot dead earlier today during a confrontation between Israeli soldiers and Palestinians in the West Bank city of Jenin. Photo: Mohammed Talatene/dpa (Photo by Mohammed Talatene/picture alliance via Getty Images)

Youngsters participate in a candlelight vigil to denounce the killing of journalist Shireen Abu Akleh on Might 11, 2022, in Gaza Metropolis.

Photograph: Mohammed Talatene/Image Alliance through Getty Photographs

One other American Killed

For weeks after Abu Akleh’s demise, her household and a rising quantity of individuals, together with members of Congress, known as on the U.S. authorities to conduct its personal unbiased investigation.

U.S. officers ultimately responded to these calls for by reviewing and “summarizing” the investigations performed by Israeli and Palestinian officers. In a assertion issued on the Fourth of July vacation, the State Division mentioned that investigators “couldn’t attain a definitive conclusion relating to the origin of the bullet” that killed Abu Akleh. Whereas they famous that “gunfire from [Israel Defense Forces] positions was seemingly accountable” for her demise, they discovered “no motive to imagine that this was intentional however moderately the results of tragic circumstances.”

It was a deeply disappointing conclusion for many who had hoped that the probe would yield stronger condemnation or a path towards accountability.

The Abu Akleh household rejected the findings, denouncing their lack of transparency and questioning their political nature. “The notion that the American investigators, whose id will not be disclosed within the assertion, imagine the bullet ‘seemingly got here from Israeli positions’ is chilly consolation,” they wrote in a blistering assertion. “We proceed to name on the American authorities to conduct an open, clear, and thorough investigation of all of the info by unbiased companies free from any political consideration or affect.” They demanded a gathering with President Joe Biden throughout his journey to Israel and the West Financial institution this week. The White Home didn’t reply a query from The Intercept about Biden’s plans to fulfill with them.

“Within the days and weeks since an Israeli soldier killed Shireen, not solely have we not been adequately consulted, knowledgeable, and supported by U.S. authorities officers,” they wrote to the president, “however your administration’s actions exhibit an obvious intent to undermine our efforts towards justice and accountability for Shireen’s demise.”

B’tselem, an Israeli human rights group, known as the end result of the U.S. evaluation a “whitewash.” A colleague of Abu Akleh’s at Al Jazeera wrote that the State Division’s assertion felt just like the journalist “was shot once more at the moment.”

Within the U.S., progressive legislators launched an modification to the protection funds to pressure the State Division and the FBI — which frequently investigates severe crimes dedicated in opposition to U.S. residents abroad — to analyze Abu Akleh’s killing, although the modification failed to go. Rep. Rashida Tlaib, D-Mich., a co-sponsor of the invoice and the primary Palestinian American in Congress, additionally known as for an ombudsman investigation of the State Division’s response.

Jamil Dakwar, a Palestinian American human rights lawyer who has suggested the Corries since 2003, advised The Intercept that the U.S. authorities was “successfully an confederate” in Israeli crimes.

“Had it been some other international authorities, there would already be a Shireen Abu Akleh and Rachel Corrie Accountability Act and sanctions leveled in opposition to that nation and its highest officers for killing an American human rights activist and journalist with impunity,” Dakwar mentioned. “Frankly, I’d not belief the US with conducting a reputable and unbiased investigation into severe abuses by shut U.S. allies equivalent to Israel. The worth tag for actual accountability is simply too excessive.”

The State Division didn’t tackle The Intercept’s questions on how U.S. officers performed their evaluation, and a division spokesperson struggled to reply reporters’ questions on it at a briefing final week. Nonetheless, the truth that such a probe even occurred, nevertheless cursory and flawed, was an indication of the rising strain the Biden administration has come underneath following Abu Akleh’s killing.

A man walks past a mural depicting slain Al Jazeera journalist Shireen Abu Akleh, who was killed while covering an Israeli army raid in Jenin in May, drawn along Israel's controversial separation barrier in the biblical city of Bethlehem in the occupied West Bank on July 6, 2022. (Photo by AHMAD GHARABLI / AFP) (Photo by AHMAD GHARABLI/AFP via Getty Images)

A person walks previous a mural of slain Al Jazeera journalist Shireen Abu Akleh within the occupied West Financial institution on July 6, 2022.

Photograph: Ahmad Gharabli/AFP through Getty Photographs

The U.S. authorities by no means investigated the killing of Rachel Corrie, regardless of dozens of members of Congress calling for such an investigation on the time. Nor has it investigated the deaths of different U.S. residents by the hands of Israeli forces, together with 18-year-old Turkish American Furkan Dogan, considered one of 9 peace activists killed by Israeli troopers in 2010 aboard the Mavi Marmara, a flotilla headed for Gaza to ship humanitarian provides; 16-year-old Mahmoud Shaalan, an unarmed Palestinian American boy killed in 2016 whereas crossing a checkpoint within the West Financial institution; and 78-year-old Omar Assad, a former Milwaukee grocery retailer proprietor who died of an obvious coronary heart assault earlier this 12 months after Israeli troopers dragged him from his automotive, then blindfolded and handcuffed him.

The U.S. authorities additionally failed to analyze extreme accidents inflicted on a number of Americans by Israeli forces, together with the 2014 beating of 15-year-old Tariq Abu Khdeir, who was visiting household in Jerusalem from Florida. A day earlier, Abu Khdeir’s 16-year-old cousin Mohammed Abu Khdeir, who was not a U.S. citizen, had been kidnapped by Israeli settlers and burned alive.

On every event, and as they did for weeks after Abu Akleh’s killing, U.S. officers — a few of them the identical people the Corries met with through the years — known as on Israel to hold out a “credible” investigation. It was listening to these phrases once more that drove the Corries to reluctantly finish their silence in regards to the conversations they’d with members of the U.S. authorities and the way fruitless the years of behind-the-scenes efforts in Washington had been.

“They shouldn’t need to be asking the very same questions we have been asking in 2003,” mentioned Sarah, talking of Abu Akleh’s household. “My query to the Biden administration is, what are you doing in another way for Shireen’s household that you simply didn’t do in our case, in order that they are going to get accountability? What’s your actual expectation right here? There must be a bit of bit extra honesty about that, and in the event that they’re not going to be trustworthy, then I’ve to talk up once more.”

Cindy Corrie holds a letter from Colin Powell expressing condolences for her daughter Rachel's death. Kholood Eid for The Intercept

Cindy Corrie holds a letter from Secretary of State Colin Powell, dated March 20, 2003, expressing condolences for her daughter Rachel’s demise.

Photograph: Kholood Eid for The Intercept

Breaking the Silence

As public as they’d been of their efforts to get solutions about Rachel’s killing, and as outspoken as they continue to be in regards to the Palestinian trigger, the Corries by no means talked intimately about their personal discussions with U.S. officers, at first as a result of they trusted that the method would yield the outcomes they have been searching for and later as a result of revisiting the odyssey felt too overwhelming. The expertise of searching for justice for Rachel, they are saying, at occasions felt simply as traumatizing as her demise itself.

“Emotionally, it’s damaging to maintain having to return and revisit it time and again,” mentioned Sarah, who stopped counting the household’s conferences with U.S. officers once they reached 200, years in the past.

“We take care of Rachel not being right here, and in a variety of methods that’s simply part of our lives,” her mom mentioned. “However the means of searching for the accountability that she deserved, that each one these individuals deserve, the depth of that … it was such an extended battle.”

Over two days final month at Sarah’s house in a suburb of Olympia, the Corries spoke at size about their conversations with senior officers, together with Blinken, CIA Director William Burns, and staffers working carefully with Biden throughout his time within the Senate and as vp. Sarah dug out the previous containers of paperwork and shared dozens of recordsdata detailing the efforts of U.S. officers to strain Israel into an investigation and their unequivocal rejection of its conclusions. The paperwork, a range of which The Intercept is publishing, embrace communications with present and former senior officers, notes from conferences, and tons of of pages the Corries obtained by public information requests, equivalent to diplomatic cables, inner State Division memorandums, and letters between the Bush and Obama administrations and members of Congress.

“The method of searching for the accountability that she deserved, that each one these individuals deserve, the depth of that … it was such an extended battle.”

Collectively, the recordsdata and the Corries’ testimony paint a damning image of the futility of U.S. efforts to hunt accountability. The paperwork present that a number of senior officers tried for months to extract solutions from their Israeli counterparts. However the lack of political will on the a part of the U.S. govt department and Congress to impose penalties for Israeli human rights abuses lowered these efforts to meaningless gestures, with all gamers concerned totally conscious that they’d result in no actual change.

Once they launched into that course of, nevertheless, the Corries knew none of this. So once they discovered that Anton Abu Akleh, Shireen’s brother, had expressed the need to fulfill with them, they readily agreed. “There isn’t any guide,” Craig mentioned of the battle for justice. “We wished to warn them.”

On a Zoom name final month, the Corries spoke to members of the Abu Akleh household, who known as in from Jerusalem and elsewhere within the U.S. Even over video, they felt instantly related.

It was a heartbreaking assembly. “It’s actually exhausting to see the scenario proceed the best way that it’s … figuring out that it could be a long time earlier than they discover any passable — or possibly unsatisfactory — reply, till the purpose that they simply get drained,” Cindy mentioned. “They’re going by the very same factor,” echoed Craig, “making an attempt to maintain management as finest as they will over this course of.”

There had been early indicators that the U.S. response to Abu Akleh’s killing could be totally different, like the truth that Blinken personally known as her household to supply the administration’s assist. Colin Powell by no means known as the Corries, they famous, although he wrote them a letter of condolence. However these hopes shortly light, and the outcomes of the U.S. probe earlier this month all however put an finish to them.

A Rafah mural in downtown Olympia, WA July 10, 2022. Kholood Eid for The Intercept

The Olympia-Rafah solidarity mural venture in downtown Olympia, Wash.

Photograph: Kholood Eid for The Intercept

“The U.S. can do no matter they need; on the finish of the day, they’re a superpower,” Lina Abu Akleh, Shireen’s niece, mentioned in an interview in June, earlier than U.S. investigators reached their conclusions. “However they haven’t been doing what they’re imagined to do, which is defend their residents outdoors of the U.S.”

In fact, it shouldn’t matter that Shireen and Rachel have been Americans — one thing the Corries have lengthy burdened all through their advocacy on Rachel’s behalf. Israeli forces have killed greater than 10,000 Palestinians because the finish of the Second Intifada in 2005, at the very least 50 this 12 months alone, nearly all with out accountability.

“The Corries have painfully discovered firsthand that whereas they have been welcomed to convey Rachel’s case to America’s halls of energy and even extract expression of sympathy from U.S. officers, Rachel’s case isn’t any totally different from 1000’s of Palestinians who have been victims of Israeli struggle crimes and crimes in opposition to humanity over the past seven a long time,” Dakwar, who co-represented the household in a civil swimsuit in opposition to the Israeli authorities, advised The Intercept.

Nonetheless, the U.S. is Israel’s closest ally, and Israel is the largest cumulative recipient of U.S. international help since World Struggle II — to the tune of $146 billion in army help and missile protection funding. The U.S.-made bulldozer that killed Rachel Corrie was bought to Israel by a Protection Division program, and the Abu Akleh household has requested U.S. officers to “make clear the extent to which American funds have been concerned” in her killing.

Whereas the Corries additionally fought a decadelong authorized battle in opposition to the Israeli authorities, they positioned larger expectations in their very own authorities’s capacity to ship justice. The U.S. authorities’s failure, ultimately, was extra devastating. “I’ve little or no say over what the Israeli authorities does, however I’ve a a lot larger accountability for what my very own authorities does,” Sarah mentioned.

As they sat in Sarah’s eating room, surrounded by art work she had collected over months spent in Haifa when the lawsuit in opposition to the Israeli authorities went to trial, the Corries generally quibbled over particulars of their recollections. They’d additionally come to course of their experiences in numerous methods. Sarah was extra outspoken about her deep frustration with U.S. officers. Cindy burdened how grateful and indebted the household felt towards the person officers who confirmed them a lot kindness. She remembered assembly former U.S. Ambassador to Israel Daniel Kurtzer in his house, as an illustration, after he left the diplomatic corps, and speaking to him for hours. “He by no means acted like we must always depart,” she mentioned. “I’m fairly certain that with all the pieces else that was happening, I by no means wrote him a thank-you be aware.”

Cindy generally feels that the household gave up preventing too quickly — that if they’d saved touring to Washington and saved pushing for extra conferences, then possibly Abu Akleh’s household wouldn’t be in the identical place at the moment.

“There’s a burden on our shoulders each time someone is significantly injured or killed, significantly when it’s a U.S. citizen; you all the time really feel like if we might have simply achieved one thing extra, that possibly we might have helped,” Sarah mentioned. “However it’s not likely a burden any household ought to carry. It truly is a burden that the US authorities ought to carry.”

Sarah Corrie sifts through old photos of her sister Rachel at home in Olympia, WA July 10, 2022. Kholood Eid for The Intercept

Sarah Corrie sifts by previous photographs of her sister, Rachel, at house in Olympia, Wash., on July 10, 2022.

Photograph: Kholood Eid for The Intercept

The Solely Individuals on the Hill

The USA invaded Iraq three days after Rachel was killed, however for weeks main as much as the assault, the prospect of struggle dominated public discourse. In emails to her dad and mom, Rachel usually wrote in regards to the impending struggle alongside accounts of Israeli violence. In her final electronic mail, she thanked them for his or her anti-war work.

With the invasion across the nook and their daughter in Gaza, Cindy and Craig Corrie had begun to comply with in her footsteps. In North Carolina, the place they lived for a short while, Cindy joined a peace group, and days earlier than Rachel’s demise she traveled to Washington, D.C., for an anti-war rally. She had by no means been on the Hill earlier than, however she and Craig had campaigned for Washington Rep. Brian Baird, so she determined to go to his workplace to relay the injustices her daughter had been writing house about. She known as Rachel from Union Station that day to ensure the small print have been correct. It was the final time they spoke.

Baird, who served in Congress till 2011, recalled assembly Cindy in an interview with The Intercept. “I advised her, ‘We’re about to launch an invasion of Iraq. … You’ve acquired to inform your daughter to be tremendous cautious proper now, as a result of with the struggle about to occur, all eyes can be away.’”

Lower than every week later, Sarah discovered of her sister’s killing when the information broke on tv. She was at house in Olympia when a pal left a voicemail telling her how sorry she was. Sarah didn’t know what she was speaking about. She turned on the information and browse, “Olympia lady killed in Rafah, Gaza.” Moments later, her sister’s title was flashing throughout the ticker.

Sarah known as everybody she knew who would possibly know someone in authorities. The household didn’t know what they have been imagined to do, whether or not they need to be touring to Israel, or learn how to convey Rachel’s physique house. When Sarah reached Baird on the cellphone, he instantly requested, “Was your mom in my workplace final week?”

Baird advised Sarah he can be on the Hill the subsequent morning to fulfill her dad and mom, who had gotten on a flight again to D.C. “I’ll assist them,” he promised. He spent the remainder of his time in Congress making good on that pledge.

“I felt an ethical obligation,” he advised The Intercept, “to make sure that our nation investigated totally how considered one of our residents was killed by a rustic that receives billions of {dollars} of U.S. international help, that we think about an ally.”

Baird’s congressional workplace turned the Corries’ headquarters for these first, frantic days, and Cindy and Craig recall that point of anguish as one interspersed with numerous gestures of humanity. On the Tuesday after Rachel was killed, a staffer introduced them sandwiches when he realized they’d not eaten since Saturday. Within the rush of leaving house, Craig had packed pillowcases as an alternative of shirts; Baird supplied him considered one of his personal. Craig remembers laughing at that: “You’re a U.S. congressman, and also you simply supplied me the shirt off your again,” to which Baird replied that he had “a clear one.” At one level, Craig lay down on the ground, overwhelmed. He remembers the congressman gently draping a blanket over him.

WASHINGTON - MARCH 19:  A photograph of peace activist Rachel Corrie (L) is on display next to her father Craig, mother Cynthia, and brother Chris Corrie March 19, 2003 in Washington, DC. Rachel Corrie was killed in the Gaza Strip by an Israeli army bulldozer March 16, 2003 as she was trying to prevent the bulldozer from destroying a Palestinian home. U.S. Representative Brian Baird (D-WA) introduced the family and is working to have the U.S. government investigate the incident.  (Photo by Stefan Zaklin/Getty Images)

The Corrie household requires a U.S. investigation into Rachel’s demise throughout a press convention hosted by Rep. Brian Baird, D.-Wash., in Washington, D.C., on March 19, 2003.

Photograph: Stefan Zaklin/Getty Photographs

The Corries spent the subsequent weeks, months, and years on an exhausting tour of Washington places of work. Baird launched a decision calling for a U.S. investigation of Rachel’s demise, and members of her household, together with uncles and aunts, hand-delivered private requests for signatures to each single workplace in Congress. Seventy-seven representatives signed on, however the invoice was by no means moved to a vote.

Sarah and Rachel had grown up in a state capital, with politically engaged dad and mom who would rush the youngsters house when there have been essential hearings on TV. Regardless of her expertise, Sarah nonetheless essentially believes within the promise of the U.S. authorities to do the best factor and of its residents’ accountability to assist it get there. “I’m very real looking, I feel anyone that has walked down the halls of Congress may be very real looking,” she mentioned. “However what do you do when you hand over on that hope?”

So the household traveled throughout the nation each three months to fulfill with anybody who would meet with them. They scheduled as many as 10 appointments a day. They’d catch in a single day flights from Seattle, shortly change, and be on the Hill by 9 a.m. Typically, Rachel’s aunts would be a part of them from Iowa, using Greyhound buses to the capital as a result of they didn’t prefer to fly. In Iowa, the place Craig and Cindy had grown up, kinfolk pounded the marketing campaign path, asking candidates to deal with Rachel’s killing.

“I feel anyone that has walked down the halls of Congress may be very real looking. However what do you do when you hand over on that hope?”

The household ready packets for everybody they met, with photographs of Rachel, background info, and clips in regards to the newest information from Palestine. Sarah carried round two giant folders labeled “Corrie Case recordsdata for Washington DC” and “Rachel Information DC Work.” After their conferences, they’d sit down in a café, with out speaking to 1 one other, to jot down down all the pieces they remembered and compile a meticulous document. It was full-time, usually discouraging work.

Somebody had suggested them early on to focus solely on Rachel’s demise, that talking out in assist of Palestinians wouldn’t get them far in Washington. “You possibly can speak about the reason for Rachel, however you may’t speak about Rachel’s trigger,” that particular person advised them. They did the other. All alongside, they have been totally conscious that few Palestinians would get the identical entry to U.S. officers — which made their sense of accountability even heavier.

Many of the work concerned educating U.S. officers about a spot and context they knew virtually nothing about. They needed to “clarify Rafah to individuals,” mentioned Sarah, pulling out maps and exhibiting the place Gaza was, the place Israel deliberate to construct a wall. “So many places of work actually didn’t have a clue,” she added. “We acknowledged in a short time that it was not nearly educating about what occurred to Rachel and making an attempt to get accountability, nevertheless it was additionally making an attempt to get some info again to them.”

Most officers and staffers listened intently and compassionately; a number of went out of their manner to assist. At one level, Sarah acquired Rep. Adam Smith, D-Wash., to hand-deliver a letter she had written to Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon. William Burns, who on the time was assistant secretary of state for Close to Jap Affairs, known as Craig to encourage him and Cindy to journey to Gaza after Rachel’s demise. “‘It’s essential go,’” Craig remembers him saying. “He wished us to see it firsthand.” The State Division had an advisory in place warning People in opposition to touring to Gaza — one thing the Israelis later used to counsel that Rachel was accountable for her personal demise. However Burns didn’t appear involved about that. “Stick with the Palestinians,” he advised the Corries. “They are going to preserve you secure.”


Craig and Cindy Corrie pose for a photograph with the Nasrallah household, whose home Rachel was defending in Rafah, Gaza, in 2003.

Photograph: Courtesy of the Corrie household

The Corries traveled to Gaza a number of occasions and met with the Nasrallah household, whose house Rachel was defending the day she was killed. A spokesperson for the CIA wrote in an announcement to The Intercept that when Burns was a State Division official, “he had the chance to fulfill with the Corries and specific his heartfelt condolences as they labored with U.S. officers to pursue a full and clear investigation of their daughter Rachel’s tragic demise — an investigation for which he strongly advocated.”

Some officers have been dismissive or unresponsive. Others merely by no means discovered time for them. As soon as, after a uncommon, disagreeable assembly throughout which a congressional staffer had berated them, a receptionist requested to fulfill the household in a discreet nook of Congress’s cafeteria, the place, watching his again, he apologized for the best way they’d been handled.

At occasions, the Corries felt like they have been barely being tolerated. They laughed when public information they obtained included a remark from a Justice Division staffer to an official in Congress, saying, “The household will not be going to go away, so sluggish strolling a call is simply going to make the committee’s life harder and subsequently yours as nicely.” In govt places of work particularly, the Corries generally felt like they have been being given the runaround. They started to jokingly confer with it as being “woozled,” after the woozles haunting Winnie the Pooh’s nightmares. “We’ve been woozled by the perfect,” Sarah advised her father once they left Blinken’s workplace for the final time.

US Secretary of State Antony Blinken (L) shakes hands with Israeli Defense Minister Benny Gantz at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs in Jerusalem on May 25, 2021. - The US top diplomat, on a regional tour this week in the Middle East, vowed support to help rebuild the battered Gaza Strip and shore up a truce between Hamas and Israel, but insisted the territory's Islamist militant rulers would not benefit from any aid. (Photo by Alex Brandon / POOL / AFP) (Photo by ALEX BRANDON/POOL/AFP via Getty Images)

U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken, left, shakes palms with Israeli Protection Minister Benny Gantz on the Ministry of International Affairs in Jerusalem on Might 25, 2021.

Photograph: Alex Brandon/AFP through Getty Photographs

Some officers advised the Corries privately what they’d by no means say publicly. A longtime congressman warned them, “No one will ever let you know no. And no person will ever do something.” A senior employees member in Biden’s workplace inspired them to maintain up their advocacy for Rachel in addition to the Palestinian individuals: “You need to preserve doing this as a result of you’re the solely individuals on the Hill speaking about this.”

There have been uplifting moments, generally humorous ones. As soon as, Sarah spilled her latte over the papers of Rep. Nancy Pelosi’s chief of employees — she instantly went to the reward store and acquired a mug with a lid, which she nicknamed “the Nancy Pelosi.” The household turned pleasant with safety guards on the Hill and the shuttle driver who ferried them to town from their low cost resort on the outskirts of D.C. After a number of journeys, the driving force requested why they saved coming again, and so they advised him Rachel’s story. From then on, he dropped them off on the Capitol with a “You go get them!”

For Baird, the household’s champion in Washington, the expertise was a disillusioning one.

Some individuals went to bat for them, he burdened, conscious that it could possibly be career-ending. “There are members of the State Division who know full nicely the imbalance of our relationship with Israel, they know full nicely the injury that does to our integrity and our standing, and so they know full nicely that their palms are tied by the American political system,” Baird mentioned. “And it breaks their coronary heart.”

“No one will ever let you know no. And no person will ever do something.”

The very best-intentioned efforts have been in the end undermined by international coverage priorities that have been at odds with the hunt for justice, Baird realized. The identical dynamic is now enjoying out within the aftermath of Abu Akleh’s killing — and the killing of U.S. resident Jamal Khashoggi, the journalist assassinated on the Saudi consulate in Istanbul on the behest of Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman. Within the absence of U.S. motion, these accountable for such abuses know that “as time passes, we are going to neglect about it,” mentioned Baird. “And that encourages them to behave with impunity.”

Baird’s biggest frustration was along with his fellow members of Congress. After talking up on behalf of the Corries, he confronted a barrage of accusations that he was antisemitic. Criticizing Israel, he shortly discovered, inevitably led to misplaced funding and votes. “For having the audacity, the hubris, the braveness possibly, to analyze the demise of 1 your individual constituents, you get primarily branded as a nonsupporter of Israel,” he mentioned. “There’s a bolstered lack of objectivity and curiosity, and there’s a bolstered, reflexive obedience and repetition of the Israeli line.”

That stage of conformity to the Israeli place has been challenged lately, as plenty of legislators have questioned U.S. assist for Israel in gentle of ongoing abuses and rising solidarity with Palestinians among the many American public. However these voices stay a small minority in Congress. Whereas some legislators have issued a flurry of statements in current months — about Abu Akleh’s killing but in addition different Israeli abuses — their considerations are a great distance from shaping U.S. international coverage.

GAZA CITY, GAZA STRIP - APRIL 13: Child members of The Mini Palestinian Parliament burn toy bulldozers as a symbol of the D9 Bulldozers made by Caterpillar Company (CAT) and supplied to the Israeli military, during a rally to commemorate the death of Rachel Corrie, April 13, 2005 in Rafah refugee camp in the southern Gaza Strip. Rachel Corrie, a U.S. volunteer with the International Solidarity Movement was killed by an Israel military bulldozer in Rafah two years ago on March 16, 2003 when she tried to prevent the demolition of a Palestinian home and during the rally the Palestinian children demanded that the Caterpillar Company (CAT) stopped the sales of the bulldozers to the Israeli army.  (Photo by Abid Katib/Getty Images)

Youngsters burn toy bulldozers in a Rafah refugee camp on April 13, 2005, throughout a rally to protest the killing of Rachel Corrie.

Photograph: Abid Katib/Getty Photographs

“Are We Going to Do Nothing?”

Lawrence Wilkerson discovered early in his time as chief of employees to the secretary of state that the US was merely “in a special relationship with Israel than some other of its allies.”

He remembers sitting in a gathering with prime Bush administration officers on the top of Israel’s focused assassination marketing campaign, in the course of the Second Intifada. Greater than as soon as, Israeli forces firing Hellfire missiles from Apache helicopters had focused militant leaders however killed youngsters and different civilians within the course of. This was a struggle crime, Wilkerson mentioned, and it was a violation of U.S. legislation, which prohibited the usage of U.S. army gross sales for the sorts of actions the Israelis have been participating in. He really helpful a strongly worded rebuke however was overruled.

“We had pictures of the ladies and kids who had died,” Wilkerson recalled. “And I mentioned, ‘That is going to occur once more, and once more, and once more. Are we going to do nothing every time?’”

He regarded across the room. “There was no reply to my query.”

Wilkerson has since come to remorse his position within the Bush administration and doesn’t mince phrases, significantly in regards to the Iraq Struggle. In an interview final month, he spoke for the primary time about the important thing position he performed in searching for accountability on behalf of the Corrie household — and the way his efforts in the end fell quick.

Powell, the secretary of state, had been locked in an influence battle with different members of Bush’s Cupboard over international coverage points, Wilkerson mentioned, and when Rachel was killed, he instructed Wilkerson to make her case a precedence, regardless that it was not for the administration. “He mentioned, ‘I need you to take this on, and I need you to do the perfect you may, and I need you to be talking for me.’”

With that mandate, Wilkerson turned a staunch advocate for the Corries, who keep in mind him, together with Baird, as one of many officers who labored the toughest to get the U.S. authorities to do one thing about Rachel’s killing. For his half, Wilkerson got here to see parallels between Rachel, as her household described her, and his personal daughter.

“We had pictures of the ladies and kids who had died. And I mentioned, ‘That is going to occur once more, and once more, and once more.’”

Within the aftermath of Rachel’s killing, Sharon had personally promised Bush that the Israeli authorities would undertake a “thorough, credible, and clear” investigation. Paperwork the household shared with The Intercept present that a number of State Division officers, together with Wilkerson, repeatedly took up the case with their Israeli counterparts, receiving related commitments.

U.S. officers additionally made commitments. “When now we have the demise of an American citizen, we wish to see it totally investigated,” Richard Boucher, a State Division spokesperson, mentioned at a public briefing three days after Rachel’s killing. “That’s considered one of our key duties abroad, to take care of the welfare of Americans and to search out out what occurred in conditions like these.”

The Israeli authorities performed two investigations. The primary, by the Israel Protection Forces, was an inquiry usually carried out by the army unit concerned in an incident and meant to determine operational points. The second, by the army police, was supposedly extra thorough. However each investigative processes are frequently mired in flaws, as human rights observers have repeatedly detailed. “On the coronary heart of the issue is a system that depends on troopers’ personal accounts as the brink for figuring out whether or not severe investigation is warranted,” Human Rights Watch concluded in a 2010 report. “Exculpatory claims of troopers are taken at face worth, at finest delaying and at worst foreclosing a immediate and neutral investigation worthy of the title.”

U.S. officers quickly got here to related conclusions in Rachel’s case. When he first noticed a duplicate of one of many two investigations — he couldn’t keep in mind which — Wilkerson advised Kurtzer, the U.S. ambassador to Israel, “This stinks.” He instructed Kurtzer to relay to the Israelis that they wanted to do “a greater investigation.” And he pressed his personal contacts throughout the Israeli army in regards to the inconsistencies within the report however “by no means acquired actually good, passable solutions.”

Different State Division officers additionally raised objections. “Many questions stay unanswered,” Kurtzer wrote in a letter to the Israeli minister of protection. “I need to inform you that my authorities doesn’t think about this matter closed.”

The complete army police report was by no means launched to the U.S. authorities, and solely after appreciable strain have been its conclusions made obtainable to U.S. officers. Later, after but extra strain, some U.S. officers have been allowed to see a duplicate of the report. Considered one of them was Richard LeBaron, deputy chief of mission on the U.S. Embassy in Tel Aviv. LeBaron flagged “a number of inconsistencies worthy of be aware” in a memo to the State Division.

The Corries have been additionally ultimately allowed to evaluation the report on the Israeli Consulate in San Francisco. The consul there had supplied his condolences after Rachel’s killing, and when Cindy thanked him for that, he burdened awkwardly that it had been “a private name,” not on behalf of his authorities. He then led the Corries right into a room the place he handed them a single paper copy of the report and advised them he can be gone however that they might keep so long as they wanted. The Corries took that as tacit permission to repeat the report phrase for phrase. Just like the operational investigation that preceded it, the army report cleared the IDF of any wrongdoing. The Intercept reviewed copies of each.

Maybe the strongest condemnation got here from Wilkerson, in a letter to the Corries a few 12 months after Rachel’s demise. “Your final query,” he wrote, “is a legitimate one, i.e., whether or not or not we view that report back to have mirrored an investigation that was ‘thorough, credible and clear.’ I can reply your query with out equivocation. No, we don’t think about it so.”

That assertion, which the Corries quoted for years as they sought additional U.S. motion on the case, had include Powell’s signoff, Wilkerson advised The Intercept. Whereas his letter to the Corries was personal, it was meant to be a document of the U.S. authorities’s rejection of the Israeli investigation. Wilkerson additionally inspired the Corries to file information requests for official deliberations in regards to the case and fast-tracked these they despatched to the State Division.

“I used to be conscious of the truth that I used to be chatting with the Corries as the US authorities,” Wilkerson advised The Intercept. “That doesn’t imply that the president agreed with me or the vp agreed with me. They in all probability couldn’t have cared much less.”

Cindy and Craig Corrie at their daughter Sarah's home in Olympia, WA July 10, 2022. Kholood Eid for The Intercept
A framed photo of Rachel Corrie at her sister Sarah Corrie's home in Olympia, WA July 10, 2022. Kholood Eid for The Intercept

Left/Prime: Cindy and Craig Corrie pose for a photograph at their daughter Sarah’s house. Proper/Backside: A framed picture of Rachel Corrie at her sister Sarah’s home.Photographs: Kholood Eid for The Intercept

Rewriting Historical past

There are a variety of legal guidelines the U.S. authorities might wield to carry Israel accountable for human rights abuses, together with provisions underneath the International Help Act, the Arms Export Management Act, and the International Magnitsky Human Rights Accountability Act, which was signed into legislation in 2017 and permits for sanctions in opposition to people “accountable for extrajudicial killings, torture, or different gross violations of internationally acknowledged human rights.”

There are additionally the “Leahy legal guidelines,” named after Sen. Patrick Leahy, which restrict the flexibility of the State and Protection departments to supply army help to international models which have a document of human rights violations.

As they looked for avenues to accountability, the Corries met with Leahy’s workplace a number of occasions, and thru public information requests, they discovered that U.S. diplomats had flagged Rachel’s killing early on as a possible “Leahy case.” However there was no impression on U.S. safety help to Israel, and whereas Caterpillar Inc. briefly suspended supply of some bulldozers to the IDF, the gross sales quickly resumed. A civil swimsuit the Corries introduced in opposition to the bulldozer producer within the U.S. was dismissed on the grounds that, as a result of the autos have been bought to Israel as a part of a U.S. army program, a ruling would intrude upon the international coverage authority of the federal government.

With Wilkerson’s assist, the Corries additionally pushed for a U.S. probe of Rachel’s demise. Just like the Abu Akleh household at the moment, they couldn’t perceive why the FBI by no means investigated her killing. To this point, the Justice Division, which would want to authorize such an inquiry, has given no indication that it plans to take action in Abu Akleh’s case.

The Corries met with a number of Justice Division officers and filed information requests to grasp why an investigation was by no means approved. Within the course of, they have been advised that no legal professional basic “previous, current, or future” would certify such an investigation in opposition to Israel. “My guess is that both [the attorney general] made the choice on his personal with a phone name to [Vice President Dick] Cheney, or Cheney made the phone name himself to the AG and made certain that he was not going to do one thing on this case,” mentioned Wilkerson. A spokesperson for the Justice Division declined to remark.

Lawrence Wilkerson is a retired United States Army Colonel and former chief of staff to United States Secretary of State Colin Powell. Wilkerson has criticized many aspects of the Iraq War, including his own preparation of Powell's presentation to the UN. (Photo by Brooks Kraft LLC/Corbis via Getty Images)

Lawrence Wilkerson, former chief of employees to Secretary of State Colin Powell, stands for a portrait on August 29, 2014.

Photograph: Brooks Kraft LLC/Corbis through Getty Photographs

By 2005, with the Israeli investigations concluded and little prospect of additional U.S. motion, the Corries determined to sue the Israeli authorities. As soon as once more, it was Wilkerson who recommended it. Throughout a late 2004 assembly with a number of senior officers held in Burns’s workplace — although Burns was not in attendance — Wilkerson raised a number of eyebrows when he unexpectedly quipped, “If it have been my daughter, I’d sue.” The household hadn’t thought-about the prospect till that time. Craig remembers asking these within the room whether or not the U.S. authorities would do something to cease the household in the event that they did sue. He already knew it wouldn’t assist.

Wilkerson advised The Intercept that he had hoped a lawsuit might provide the Corries the satisfaction of a authorized authority ordering the Israeli authorities to at the very least reopen the investigation into Rachel’s killing. “After we struck out fully with the AG, with the IDF, with the ambassador, and with the Israeli authorities, I mentioned to them, ‘There’s one component of Israel’s energy that’s nonetheless legit: It’s the courtroom system,’” he recalled. “In fact, by the point they acquired into the courtroom system — it’s my view anyway — it had been corrupted too.”

It took 5 extra years for the trial to start. The Corries relocated to Haifa for months on finish. They described the proceedings as a “kangaroo trial,” a “farce.” The hearings, held in Hebrew, have been riddled with delays and errors, with translators generally relaying to the decide the very reverse of what somebody had testified. Sarah knew on day one which they have been by no means going to win.

HAIFA, ISRAEL - 28 AUGUST:  (L-R) Sister Sarah Corrie, father Craig Corrie and mother Cindy Corrie of US peace activist Rachel Corrie sit in the Haifa District Court on August 28, 2012 in Haifa, Israel. 23-year-old Rachel Corrie was run over by an Israeli army bulldozer in Gaza in 2003. Judge Oded Gershon and the Israeli court have reached a verdict today statting that Israel is not to blame for her death and that it was a ''regrettable accident''.  (Photo by Avishag Shaar-Yashuv/Getty Images)

The Corrie household sits within the Haifa District Courtroom on August 28, 2012, in Haifa, Israel.

Photograph: Avishag Shaar-Yashuv/Getty Photographs

Nonetheless, the household confirmed up for each listening to. They obtained the courtroom transcripts, paid for them to be translated, and despatched them to a number of places of work on the State Division so there can be a document someplace within the U.S. authorities, Sarah mentioned. She wished the U.S. authorities to bear witness to the trial, and each time a listening to was scheduled, she notified the embassy prematurely, asking the workplace to ship a consultant to the courtroom.

On the day of the bulldozer driver’s testimony — behind a display screen defending his id — the Israelis had packed the small courtroom in order that journalists and human rights observers couldn’t get in. Sarah needed to argue with courtroom officers to ensure the U.S. consul basic can be allowed into the room. Nonetheless, U.S. representatives weren’t there in an official capability and made no feedback. On just one event, outdoors Israel’s Supreme Courtroom, the consul hugged Craig earlier than the cameras — as near an announcement of assist because the U.S. authorities would give.

“You need to doc all the pieces. As a result of down the street, in historical past, it’ll all be rewritten to the best way that someone else desires it to be, and that gained’t be the reality.”

The yearslong trial was harrowing for the household, nevertheless it was additionally a chance to lastly get some solutions. In courtroom, the Corries discovered that the coroner within the case was nonetheless in possession of components of Rachel’s physique, a decade after her demise. Sarah screamed when she discovered. The household had agreed to the post-mortem on the situation {that a} consultant from the U.S. Embassy be within the room. However no person from the embassy was there — the workplace later mentioned it was not conscious that had been the household’s want. The Corries in the end acquired Rachel’s final stays in 2016, after yet one more lawsuit.

In 2012, an Israeli district courtroom decide dominated that the IDF was to not blame for Rachel’s demise and that she alone was accountable. The household appealed, and in 2015, 10 years after they first sued, the Supreme Courtroom of Israel upheld the ruling.

By that time, the Corries’ battle had moved on to making sure that the U.S. authorities didn’t backtrack on its earlier condemnation of the Israeli investigation. The “whitewash” had already begun, mentioned Sarah, whose lobbying in later years turned about difficult the “rewriting of historical past.” That’s partially why she saved such an intensive document. “You need to doc all the pieces,” she mentioned. “As a result of down the street, in historical past, it’ll all be rewritten to the best way that someone else desires it to be, and that gained’t be the reality.”

A pile of documents involving Rachel Corrie's death is stacked at Sarah Corrie's home in Olympia, WA July 10, 2022. Kholood Eid for The Intercept

Binders of paperwork relating to Rachel’s killing are stacked at Sarah’s house in Olympia, Wash., on July 10, 2022.

Photograph: Kholood Eid for The Intercept

Because the years handed, U.S. statements in regards to the killing in press briefings and State Division reviews grew weaker. In annoyed emails to Blinken, Burns, and others, Sarah reminded them that the U.S. authorities itself had discovered the Israeli investigation to lack credibility. “There isn’t any strolling again,” she wrote. “It’s unacceptable for the Administration to repeatedly reiterate these positions in correspondence, conversations, and so forth. with our household, in unequivocally sturdy phrases, however then fail to deal with them as forcefully when requested for public remark.”

On the final public point out of the case from a U.S. official, in 2015, then-State Division spokesperson Jen Psaki mentioned that officers didn’t have “something new” to say about it.

“The fact of it’s, there’ll by no means be the reality,” Wilkerson now says. He additionally supplied a phrase of warning in regards to the U.S. authorities’s repeated failure to carry Israel accountable for its crimes. “This was my level the entire time I used to be in authorities, and it’s my level now to whomever will pay attention: We’re not being ally. We’re setting Israel as much as one, apartheid, two, pariah standing within the worldwide neighborhood, and three, an untenable future. … This isn’t good for Israel.”

Sarah Corrie sifts through old photos of her sister Rachel at home in Olympia, WA July 10, 2022. Kholood Eid for The Intercept

Sarah sifts by previous photographs of her sister, Rachel.

Photograph: Kholood Eid for The Intercept

Most Highly effective Individuals within the World

The Corries first met Blinken in Jerusalem in March 2010. Biden had despatched Blinken, then nationwide safety adviser to the vp, in his place after the household requested a gathering. Simply earlier than the assembly, Israeli officers seized on Biden’s journey to the area to announce the development of 1,600 new unlawful settlements in East Jerusalem. Blinken was livid and made no secret of it.

The episode was emblematic of the methods through which U.S. officers would specific anger and indignation about Israel privately, difficulty cautious, crucial statements, after which in the end do nothing to make sure penalties.

In Might, Sarah watched the video of a Palestinian American scholar snubbing Blinken’s handshake at a commencement ceremony, in protest of the administration’s response to Abu Akleh’s killing. When he later met with that scholar, Blinken reportedly advised her, “I see you, and I hear you.”

Sarah thought he was honest. She and her dad and mom had been there earlier than, experiencing each the real compassion of U.S. officers and its pointlessness within the absence of significant motion. It was a failure bigger than the secretary of state or some other particular person official, they got here to grasp. However these have been probably the most highly effective individuals on the earth, and so they had achieved nothing. The USA authorities had been impotent.

“These are good individuals. They’re good individuals who nonetheless, so far as our international coverage is worried, can’t get accountability and may’t get the job achieved,” Sarah mentioned. “I do know they need accountability for Shireen. However they’ve acquired to be prepared to spend the political power to exit and get accountability.”

The Biden administration’s willingness to spend political capital for the sake of accountability stays very a lot doubtful.

On Wednesday, hours earlier than the president arrived in Israel, Blinken known as Shireen Abu Akleh’s household to ask them to go to the White Home, although he supplied no timeline, her niece advised The Intercept. The household nonetheless doesn’t know whether or not the president will meet them throughout his journey.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


Related articles

The Benefits of a Creative Subscription with Envato Elements

If you’re looking to find and use royalty-free images and other creative resources, it can be tough to...

Get an Additional ₹100 Cashback When You Pay with Domino’s Digital Wallet Partners

How does ₹100 cashback sound? Find out more about the additional cashback you can get when you pay...

Get Unlimited Access to DataCamp’s Library of Online Courses

DataCamp subscriptions enable access to over 300 courses, as well as projects, assessments, and additional content. Whether you're...

Why You Should Buy from DaMENSCH: The Best in Quality, Service, and Value

Buying products online can be dangerous; you never know if you’re getting an authentic product, or one that’s...